We may earn a small commission from product links. Blog posts at Nimble Made are written to provide value and advice for our readers—any product(s) we recommend are items readers use and love.
Written by Colin Ma
Untucked dress shirts are becoming more popular in men’s style, and you may be keen on trying out this new trend. Before you hop on the bandwagon, though, there are certain requirements that need to be met to pull off the best untucked shirts.
Too long, and you can end up looking like you're wearing someone else’s dress shirt. Too short, and it can come off as unflattering and inappropriate.
Both of these options can make you appear more awkward and confused than stylish. When you factor in slim fit shirts, the shirt length becomes even more important.
To prevent any fashion faux pas, choose men’s dress shirts that are designed to work both tucked and untucked to get the most for your money and your wardrobe. Below are our favorite picks for the best shirts to wear untucked.
Comparing the Best Untucked Shirts
|1. [Overall Favorite] Nimble Made - The Melati||
Well, a wedding is one of the most memorable days in one’s life. Therefore, it is vital to set the scene to be refined and unique. Additionally, the photographs will capture every person attending the event. Thus, the guests should understand what they need to put on to ensure the day is perfect.
A black tie dress code denotes an official evening occasion where men are supposed to wear tuxedos while the ladies put on floor-length gowns. The rules have been relaxed over the years, and people are not as strict with the dress codes as they used to be in earlier years.
However, if you are to hold a black tie wedding, even if the men will not be in tuxedos, they should wear dinner jackets and exquisite shoes with matching pants. Here's a recent guide on how to measure your waist for pants.
Best Shirts to Wear Untucked
Nimble Made is one of the top brands for finding the best button down shirts for men that fit comfortably and arguably the brand with the best untucked dress shirts with many shirts designed to be untucked.
Every shirt is designed with style and function in mind, and the website helps you find your perfect fit with a size finder tool. With its classic white patterns, button down collar, contrast stitching, and angled cuffs, this button down dress shirt will help you look just as polished and fashionable. Making these button-downs one of the best untucked button down dress shirts on the market.
- Great for being worn untucked AND tucked
- 100% cotton broadcloth with minimal shine and texture
- Semi-spread collar and metal collar stays
- Machine washable
- Easy-iron or steam for best results
- Free shipping, exchanges, and returns on U.S. orders
Real Customer Reviews: "These dress shirts fit perfectly and have a killer cut through the torso. I bought a blue one for work, wore it just once and bought the same shirt in white for my wedding - and didn’t even think twice. It took me ten years (and a lot of wasted money) to find a dress shirt that fits me this well." – Tommy K
2. Nimble Made White Dress Shirt - The Crescent
Nimble Made doesn’t just offer patterned shirts. We also offer classic styles for our best untucked shirts. From white dress shirts to light blue dress shirts, they have all of the essential shirts you need in your wardrobe. The Crescent is our number one selling shirt in a broadcloth fabric. It features a 100% cotton construction that is machine washable, making it easy to care for.
A white dress shirt is a staple in any wardrobe due to its timeless appeal, versatility, and ability to effortlessly elevate any outfit, making it suitable for formal events, professional settings, business casual environments, and semi-formal occasions.
Real Customer Reviews: “As a skinny guy around 60 kg. I spend 10 year trying to find a dress shirt that fits me well, and even though I live in Europe and have to pay shipping and taxes, I ONLY buy Nimble-Made!” - Alexander H
3. Nimble Made Dark Navy Checked Button Up Shirt - The Abacus
Gingham shirts are another staple in a man’s wardrobe. Maybe the most iconic gingham shirt is navy blue. These shirts are one of the best shirts to wear untucked because of their versatility. A navy gingham shirt can be worn with a suit or untucked with a pair of jeans.
A dark navy gingham button-up collar shirt for men is a versatile and stylish addition to any wardrobe. It can be worn for both casual and semi-formal occasions, depending on how it is styled. The gingham pattern adds a touch of visual interest, while the dark navy color provides a sophisticated and modern look.
This shirt can be paired with slim fit jeans or chinos for a more casual style, or with dress pants for a semi-formal ensemble. Its versatility and fashionable appeal make it a must-have staple for any man's wardrobe.
Real Customer Reviews: “These shirts fit perfectly. The fit on the body is just right and the sleeves are evenly tapered throughout the arm.” - Gautam R
4. Nimble Made Collared Button Up Blue Shirt - The Waterbend
Along with the white shirt, the light blue dress shirt is one of the most versatile shirts a guy can have in his closet. Wear tucked with a suit or wear this shirt untucked with a pair of jeans or chinos for a casual look that will work in most offices and for a night on the town. If you’re looking to stock your wardrobe, light blue shirts are a great starting point.
This blue dress shirt with a herringbone weave is a sophisticated and stylish choice that adds a subtle yet distinctive texture to your outfit. The herringbone pattern, characterized by a distinctive V-shaped weave, gives the shirt a refined and elegant look.
The blue color adds versatility, allowing it to be easily paired with a variety of suit colors, such as navy, gray, or charcoal. These long sleeve shirts are suitable for formal or professional settings, providing a polished and classic appearance. Its combination of a timeless color and an eye-catching herringbone weave makes it a staple piece in any well-dressed individual's wardrobe.
Real Customer Reviews: “Received my first two shirts. I swim in most dress, shirts but these fit surprisingly well ( I did order one size larger than recommended). Quality of material is good and fit at neck was very comfortable. Sleeves might be a little short, but I had difficulty making that determination. All in all a good value for a shirt that fits.” - Dave
This is a solid white t-shirt that is a perfect fit for those going for a untucked casual look. These are the best untucked shirts in a slim fit that flatters your figure. We highly recommend trying these out. They're made of 100% cotton so the fabric will feel soft on your skin. A white shirt is an essential piece in everyone's closet so I'd stock up to have a few of these best untucked shirts in your wardrobe.
This white crewneck t-shirt made in the USA from 100% cotton is a classic and high-quality wardrobe essential. Its simplicity and versatility make it a staple piece for casual, everyday wear.
The white color provides a clean and timeless look that can be effortlessly paired with jeans, shorts, or even layered under jackets or sweaters. The 100% cotton shirt ensures comfort, breathability, and durability.
Overall, this white crewneck t-shirt offers a reliable and stylish foundation for a variety of casual outfits. Here's our full guide on the best t-shirts for skinny guys.
Real Customer Reviews: “Really love the fit! I received three shirts of different fabrics and prices. They all fit really well without being too tight or baggy.” - Sean
Thanks to their casual feel, slim fit flannel shirts belong on any list of the best untucked button down shirts. The Script is a best-selling flannel shirt in a black and white plaid design made of cotton fabric. It boasts an unrivaled slim fit and a classic black and white pattern. From casual Fridays to weekend errands and date nights, wearing a flannel shirt is a perfect choice.
Flannel shirts like this black and white plaid flannel for men is a classic and versatile wardrobe piece. The plaid pattern adds visual interest and a rugged, outdoorsy vibe to the shirt. Flannel fabric is known for its warmth and comfort, making it perfect for cooler weather.
The black and white color combination offers a timeless and stylish look that can be easily paired with jeans or chinos for a casual and relaxed outfit. Flannel shirts are often associated with a laid-back, rustic aesthetic and is suitable for various occasions, from casual gatherings to outdoor activities. It's a versatile piece that adds character and a touch of nostalgia to any man's wardrobe. You'll also want to add one of these best black dress shirts to your closet as well.
Real Customer Reviews: “I love the fit of the shirts. You can definitely tell there is quality there as well. I can't wait for new styles to come out!” - Roy
Throw this staple navy tshirt into the mix because you'll find that this is an essential shirt to have when going for an untucked casual look. This is one of the best untucked shirts for men. They are slightly slimmer and shorter in length, making them a great quality shirt to have.
This navy t-shirt made from 100% cotton is a classic and versatile wardrobe staple. The blue color offers a refined and timeless look that can easily be dressed up or down.
The 100% cotton shirt ensures comfort, breathability, and durability, making it ideal for everyday wear. This type of t-shirt can be paired with jeans, chinos, or shorts for a casual and relaxed look.
It can also be layered under jackets or paired with more formal pieces for a smart-casual outfit. The versatility of a navy t-shirt makes it a go-to option for various occasions and a reliable choice for any man's wardrobe.
Real Customer Reviews: “I'm 5'8 ~135 pounds. Size N2 fits better than all other off the rack shirts I've tried. I'd be happy to see more variations on the classic/conservative styles for business attire.” - Phillip
Another great non-iron shirt option is solid black. Black wardrobe pieces are extremely versatile and a black shirt will go with almost any pair of chinos in your closet. A slim fit black shirt is an absolute must-have and one of the best dress shirts you can wear untucked.
This non-iron black dress shirt is a convenient and stylish choice for formal or professional settings. The non-iron feature saves you time and effort by minimizing wrinkles, ensuring a polished appearance throughout the day.
Long sleeve shirts like this black color adds a sleek and sophisticated touch, making it suitable for formal events, business meetings, or any occasion where a more formal attire is required.
Pair it with dress pants and a blazer for a classic and refined look, or wear it with a suit for a more formal ensemble. The non-iron feature of the shirt ensures a sharp and crisp appearance, allowing you to look put-together and professional without the hassle of ironing.
Real Customer Reviews: “This shirt was a great fit for my partner and that's rarely (never? :)) the case for off the rack shirts!” - Irina
A solid black shirt is such a versatile item to have in your closet. Wearing a black t-shirt untucked with a pair of khakis or jeans is a great look that can work in a variety of settings. We recommend this black shirt because it's shortened in length and slimmer than most shirts you can find in stores.
This black V-neck t-shirt offers a sleek and modern option for casual or semi-casual outfits. The black color adds a touch of sophistication and versatility to your wardrobe.
The V-neck design provides a stylish and flattering neckline, creating a more elevated look compared to a regular crewneck t-shirt. Its versatility and low-maintenance nature make it a practical and stylish addition to any wardrobe.
Real Customer Reviews: “No tailoring needed, I am 5'11, 155 pounds and the N3 fit me very well. Fabric quality overall is good but it varies based on the shirt style.” - Jimmy
How to Choose the Best No Tuck Shirt?
Opt for Versatility in Your Wardrobe
Look for a shirt that can be easily dressed up or down, allowing you to wear it for different occasions. Neutral colors or subtle patterns tend to be more versatile and can be paired with different bottoms and accessories.
Consider Quality and Price
Consider the quality of construction, stitching, and fabric. Opt for a shirt that is well-made and durable, ensuring it will withstand regular wear. Also, consider your budget and find a balance between quality and affordability.
Research Brand and Reviews
Look for reputable brands known for their shirt quality and fit like Nimble Made. Additionally, check customer reviews to gain insights into the shirt's fit, comfort, and overall satisfaction.
Tips When Wearing the Best Untucked Shirts
Get the Right Fit
Your shirt needs to flatter your frame, rather than hiding it or accentuating flaws. If your shirt is too baggy, you can look like a little boy wearing their father’s shirt, or having to borrow one from a friend. Here's a guide on how a dress shirt should fit.
Too tight, and your body can appear squished into the shirt, making you appear to have grown out of your clothing. Aim for a slightly fitted fit to allow for movement, while also following your frame with the proper sleeve length.
Length Is Important
The length of your shirt can completely ruin the overall look and fit, making it important to pay attention to just where it will land on your frame. A tucked shirt isn’t going to be as closely scrutinized. But when worn untucked, the length is obvious, meaning you should aim for the ideal length. Here's a separate guide for best dress shirts for tall skinny men.
A shirt should come down to the middle of your pants zipper, while also showing some of the pockets of your pants.
Don’t Rock Wrinkles
Wrinkles never enhance your look. Even slight wrinkles can make you appear lazy and like you aren’t putting your best foot forward. Keeping your shirts hung up, provide them space to not get squished by other items, and avoid letting them lay around after being cleaned.
You can also iron or steam your shirts for a crisper look. If you don’t want to go through the process of ironing or steaming, you can also go with a shirt made of wrinkle-free materials.
Make It Personal
You can add a more personal touch to the untucked shirt with colors, patterns, pocket squares, ties, pins, or just simply rolling up your sleeves. You can also finish the look with interesting socks, the right color pants, and some great shoes to make the look more reflective of your personal style. The best untucked shirts for you are the ones that will match your style.
Frequently asked questions about the best untucked shirts for men
What is the best alternative to UNTUCKit?
The best alternative at a comparable price is Nimble Made due to their proprietary Actually Slim Fit that comes with a shortened shirt length.
What shirt looks good untucked?
A casual button-down shirt or a polo shirt often looks good when worn untucked.
What shirts are best to not tuck in?
Shirts with a straight hemline or a shorter length, such as casual button-down shirts, polo shirts, or T-shirts, are generally best left untucked for a relaxed and casual look.
Are untucked shirts in style?
Yes, untucked shirts have been in style for a while now. They offer a more casual and effortless aesthetic and are popular for both men and women in various social settings.